Skip to main content

Sterling Accident

HomeAdviceNon-fault accident insurance premiums

UK motor insurance advice

Does a Non-Fault Accident Affect Your Car Insurance Premium?

Yes, it can. Even when another driver caused the collision and their insurer pays the costs, your renewal quote may still increase. That does not necessarily mean you have lost your no-claims discount.

Find out why the price can change, how insurers record non-fault claims and what to check if a settlement or renewal looks wrong.

This is general information for UK drivers. Individual premiums, insurer decisions and no-claims discounts vary by policy and circumstances.

Vehicle claim being reviewed following a road traffic accident
Non-fault is not a price guaranteeYour insurer may still assess future risk differently.
Discount and premium are separateAn intact no-claims discount does not freeze your renewal price.
Accurate claim records matterCheck whether the claim was recorded as recovered, outstanding or notification only.

A non-fault accident can feel doubly unfair: somebody else damages your car, then your insurance renewal costs more. The key is to distinguish the base insurance price, the no-claims bonus or discount, and the status of the claim. They can change independently.

The Financial Ombudsman Service explains that an insurer may use an incident as one factor when assessing the risk of future claims, including incidents where no claim was made. It can still be appropriate to challenge errors, unsupported adjustments or unclear explanations. Read the Ombudsman’s guidance on fault claims and no-claims bonuses.

Non-Fault Accidents: What Can Change?

The incident record, no-claims discount and premium are different things. The outcome depends on whether a claim was made, responsibility established, costs recovered and the insurer’s terms.

SituationNo-claims discountRenewal premium
Notification only, no claimNormally no reduction simply for reporting the incidentMay still increase if the insurer considers the incident a risk factor
Non-fault claim, responsibility establishedIf non-fault is established by renewal, existing years should not be reduced merely because the file is still open. A new no-claims year may not accrue if you made a claim.May still change even when the other insurer pays
Claim still disputed or costs unrecoveredMay be affected while the insurer investigates, subject to the facts at renewal and policy termsMay be affected; ask for a review if the claim is later resolved in your favour

See the Financial Ombudsman Service guidance on fault claims and no-claims bonuses. This table is general UK guidance, not a prediction of a particular insurer’s decision.

What the renewal quote reflects

Why can your premium rise after a non-fault accident?

An insurance premium is a price based on the risk and cover the insurer is prepared to accept at the time it quotes. Claims history is one input, but the cost can also change because of the vehicle, postcode, policy cover, repair costs, insurer pricing or broader market conditions.

The Financial Ombudsman recognises that insurers may consider a reported incident when assessing the likelihood of future claims. This is different from saying that the policyholder legally caused the original crash. There is no universal percentage increase for a non-fault accident; different companies may price the same history differently.

Who caused the accident?

The evidence and liability decision address responsibility for the collision and who may ultimately bear the claim costs.

What will insurance cost next year?

An insurer makes a separate pricing decision using its own risk factors and underwriting rules, alongside the disclosed accident history.

Asking an insurer to correct a wrong liability record is legitimate. But a correctly recorded non-fault accident may still affect the renewal quote even where all the costs are recovered from the other driver’s insurer.

Interactive example

Compare last year’s premium with a renewal quote

See how the annual price can change even when the no-claims discount stays the same. These inputs are illustrative insurer prices before any discount.

Previous annual price£360
Illustrative renewal price£480
Difference per year+£120

This calculator does not estimate the effect of an accident, predict insurance quotes or establish why a renewal price changed. Insurers calculate actual discounts and premiums in different ways; compare like-for-like quotes.

Bottom line: being blameless and having your claim fully recovered do not automatically guarantee the same or a lower premium next year.

A frequently misunderstood distinction

Will a non-fault accident affect your no-claims bonus?

It can affect the no-claims position while a claim remains unresolved. If you claim for your own vehicle damage, your insurer may temporarily treat the claim as having unrecovered costs until it recovers those costs from the responsible party. What happens at renewal depends on the actual claim status and policy terms.

The Financial Ombudsman states that, if responsibility has been resolved in your favour by renewal, your existing no-claims bonus should not be reduced simply because the claim remains technically open. If a reduction was applied while costs remained unrecovered, it may need to be corrected once the position is resolved.

However, an accident year in which you made an insurance claim might not earn an additional year of no-claims bonus even when that claim was non-fault. That is different from taking away years you had already earned.

Does protected no-claims bonus stop your premium rising?

No. Protection generally concerns how the no-claims discount is applied, subject to the particular policy. It does not lock the insurer’s base price. You may retain the same discount years and still receive a more expensive quote.

Sources: Financial Ombudsman: fault and non-fault claims and MoneyHelper: protecting no-claims bonuses.

Check what the insurer has recorded

Non-fault, fault and notification-only: what is the difference?

In insurance administration, the word fault can refer to whether the insurer recovered its money, rather than solely to the driver’s conduct on the road. A crash you did not cause can appear as a fault claim if the costs could not be recovered, such as a hit-and-run with no identified responsible insurer.

Non-fault claim with costs recovered

The insurer has recovered the relevant outlay from the responsible party. Check that any temporary no-claims adjustment has been corrected and that the final status is accurate.

Open or unrecovered claim

The insurer may temporarily record the claim in a way that affects no-claims calculations while liability or cost recovery is unresolved. Ask what is outstanding and how the record will be reviewed.

Notification only — no claim

You informed the insurer of an incident, but did not claim and no third-party payment was made. This generally should not reduce your no-claims bonus, though the incident itself may still be considered when setting a premium.

If you reported an incident without claiming and the insurer has incorrectly recorded a fault claim, that is worth challenging. In a published Ombudsman case, an incorrectly recorded fault claim was corrected, including the related industry database entry and the resulting overpaid premium. That outcome was specific to the evidence; it does not guarantee the same result for every case.

Do not omit accidents when asked: Most policies require incident disclosure according to their wording, and applications or renewals commonly ask about accidents even when no insurance claim was made. Answer accurately rather than assuming that non-fault incidents can be left out.

Does claiming directly from the other driver’s insurer avoid a premium increase?

Not necessarily. Claiming against a third party instead of using your own insurer can change who deals with repairs and pays the claim, but it does not make the accident disappear from your disclosure history. Follow the notification terms of your own policy and give accurate information when applying for or renewing cover. A notification-only record should not be treated as a paid claim merely because you reported the incident.

Do you have to pay an excess after a non-fault accident?

If you claim under your own policy, you may have to pay the applicable excess initially, even if you did not cause the collision. You may be able to recover it from the responsible party or their insurer once liability is established, but recovery is not guaranteed. Ask who will pursue the excess, what evidence is needed and whether any legal expenses cover can help. MoneyHelper explains how recovering a non-fault excess works.

A practical renewal checklist

Five checks before renewing after a non-fault accident

  • 1

    Confirm the claim’s exact status

    Ask whether the incident is recorded as non-fault, open with unrecovered costs, fault for recovery purposes or notification only. Keep the insurer’s explanation in writing.

  • 2

    Check your no-claims evidence

    Compare your previous no-claims entitlement with the renewal statement, and ask for an explanation of any step-back, withheld year or correction that should have been made.

  • 3

    Check all declared accident details

    Make sure dates, drivers, claim amounts where asked, liability outcome and claim status match the known facts. Ask the insurer to correct inaccuracies before comparing quotes.

  • 4

    Compare equivalent cover and excess

    Obtain comparable quotes using truthful information about the incident and the same cover needs. Consider the voluntary excess, use, mileage and any additional drivers rather than looking only at the annual price.

  • 5

    Request a pricing explanation if necessary

    If the renewal appears unexpectedly high, ask which recorded facts and changes contributed to the quote. Where you find a material error, put your challenge in writing.

For the vehicle claim itself, Sterling’s non-fault accident claims service explains the separate route for evidence, vehicle recovery, repairs and eligible temporary transport.

Need practical help after a non-fault collision?

Sterling Accident can assess qualifying accident-related vehicle needs and coordinate recovery, repairs or eligible replacement transport. Your insurer remains responsible for premium and no-claims decisions.

Report Your Accident →
When the record or quote looks wrong

How to challenge an incorrect fault record or premium increase

First distinguish a lawful risk-based renewal increase from an error. The stronger complaint is usually specific: the insurer recorded a claim that was only a notification, failed to update a fully recovered non-fault claim, applied the wrong no-claims years or relied on incorrect circumstances.

  • Request the accident/claims record, status, recovery position and no-claims calculation.
  • Gather claim closure correspondence, liability correspondence and previous no-claims statements.
  • Ask the insurer to correct its own record and any relevant shared industry record if information is inaccurate.
  • If unresolved, complain to the insurer’s complaints team, stating the correction and review you want.

For most insurance complaints, the firm normally has up to eight weeks to issue a final response. Eligible complaints can generally be referred to the Financial Ombudsman Service after that response or the applicable deadline; the usual referral period after a final response is six months. Check the specific time limits for your case.

Example request to your insurer

Subject: Request to review non-fault claim record and renewal — [policy number]

I am reviewing the information used for my motor insurance renewal following the incident on [date]. My understanding is that the accident was [non-fault with costs recovered / still being investigated / notification only].

Please confirm the incident status on your records, the amount of no-claims bonus you have applied and whether any recovery or correction is outstanding. I have enclosed [supporting correspondence].

If any information has been recorded incorrectly, please update it and confirm whether my renewal quote needs to be recalculated. Thank you.

Not every premium increase is caused by an error or will be overturned. The insurer should nevertheless assess a supported factual challenge fairly. The Ombudsman has explained how it considers cases involving misrecorded incidents, lost no-claims bonuses and unclear premium increases.

Official reference: Financial Ombudsman Service guidance for insurers, updated September 2026.

Answers for UK drivers

Non-fault accident insurance FAQs

Will my insurance go up even if the accident was not my fault?

It may. Insurers can use claims and incident history as part of pricing, even if you did not cause the accident. The amount and whether there is any increase depend on the insurer, policy and other rating factors.

Will a non-fault claim reduce my existing no-claims discount?

An unresolved claim may temporarily affect the discount until the insurer determines responsibility or recovers costs. A resolved non-fault position should be reflected appropriately at renewal. An additional year of no-claims may not accrue for a policy year in which you made a claim.

If the other driver’s insurer pays, why could my premium rise?

Cost recovery determines who ultimately pays for that accident. Renewal pricing is a separate underwriting decision using risk factors and your recorded incident history.

Does protecting my no-claims bonus protect the premium?

No. No-claims protection and the base premium are different. Retaining the discount does not guarantee the renewal price will stay unchanged.

What if I only notified my insurer but made no claim?

A genuine notification-only incident normally should not reduce your no-claims bonus, but the event may still affect the insurer’s risk assessment. Ask for a written correction if a fault claim has been recorded incorrectly.

Can a hit-and-run be recorded as a fault claim even if I did nothing wrong?

Yes. In insurance terms, a claim may be classed as fault when the insurer cannot recover its costs from another party. This differs from a finding that you caused the collision.

Will a non-fault claim increase my car insurance by a set percentage?

No. There is no standard percentage increase for a non-fault incident. An insurer may consider the recorded accident alongside vehicle, driver and market-related pricing factors. Compare equivalent renewal quotes and ask for a record correction if the information is wrong.

Will I have to pay an excess for a non-fault claim?

You may have to pay your policy excess upfront when claiming under your own insurance. Depending on liability and recovery, you might reclaim it from the responsible party or their insurer. Ask who will pursue recovery and do not assume reimbursement is guaranteed.

Does claiming directly from the other driver’s insurer avoid declaring the accident?

No. Answer your insurer’s and new insurer’s accident-history questions truthfully and follow any policy notification condition even if you do not claim on your own policy.

How long can a non-fault accident affect insurance premiums?

There is no single fixed period or guaranteed percentage change. Different insurers ask about and assess accident history over different periods. Answer each insurer’s questions accurately and ask it what information it used in its quote.

Do I need to declare an accident if I did not claim?

Disclose the incident when your policy requires notification or an insurance application asks about accidents or incidents, even if you paid for repairs yourself or recovered costs from a third party. Reporting without making a claim normally should not reduce your no-claims bonus.

How do I check or correct an inaccurate claim status?

Ask the insurer what it recorded, request the underlying claim and recovery information, provide supporting evidence and seek correction in writing. If necessary, make a formal complaint and consider the Financial Ombudsman route where eligible.

Accident management support

Need help after a non-fault accident?

Sterling Accident can review the reported collision and coordinate qualifying vehicle recovery, assessment, repairs and replacement transport options. Your insurer handles its own premium and no-claims decisions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *