Home›Car accident claims›Poor Insurance Accident Repairs? How to Raise a Complaint
Poor Insurance Accident Repairs? How to Raise a Complaint
If accident repairs leave your vehicle with a mismatched panel, warning lights, leaks or unfinished work, document the defect and ask the insurer and repairer to investigate. Who is responsible for the remedy often depends on whether your own insurer authorised and arranged the repair.
General UK vehicle-claims information. Insurance cover, liability, eligibility and any financial recovery depend on your policy, agreement and evidence.

If accident repairs leave your vehicle with a mismatched panel, warning lights, leaks or unfinished work, document the defect and ask the insurer and repairer to investigate. Who is responsible for the remedy often depends on whether your own insurer authorised and arranged the repair.
Who should fix a poor insurance repair?
If your own insurer selected and appointed the workshop under the policy, the Financial Ombudsman normally holds the insurer responsible for the standard of that repair, even where the garage is a separate business.
If you selected a garage independently or signed a separate credit-repair contract, responsibility can be different. Identify who instructed the repairs, who signed the repair agreement and who paid before making demands.
- Whether your insurer arranged the repair
- Who authorised the original estimate and supplements
- What repair guarantee or warranty was given
- Whether the concern is workmanship, safety, parts or delay
What counts as an unsatisfactory repair?
Examples include paint mismatch, obvious panel gaps, recurring faults linked to the accident, damaged trim, poor corrosion protection and unaddressed safety equipment. It helps to identify each specific issue and explain why you believe it relates to the repair.
Ask an appropriate specialist to assess urgent mechanical, structural, braking or restraint concerns. A car that appears cosmetically repaired is not necessarily safe; stop using it if roadworthiness is uncertain.
Take dated close-up and wider photographs of each concern, note warning messages, and retain the collection and repair paperwork.
How should you document the complaint?
Write a precise defect list linked to original repair items, not simply ‘the car looks bad’. For paint concerns, photograph in consistent daylight; for intermittent faults, note circumstances and any diagnostic messages.
Ask for written garage findings and whether a reinspection will be arranged. An independent engineer’s report may be helpful for technical disagreements, but agree how it will be used and who pays before commissioning it.
The Financial Ombudsman motor repairs guidance describes how it assesses poor workmanship and repairs that did not restore the vehicle appropriately.
Can you insist on a different garage?
You can request a different remedy or an independent check where confidence has been lost, but there is not an unconditional right to choose any garage and have all costs paid. The insurer may reasonably be allowed to inspect or correct its original repair.
Do not authorise an expensive replacement repair elsewhere without considering whether your insurer has an opportunity to put the problem right, unless urgent safety concerns require appropriate action.
When can the complaint go to the Financial Ombudsman?
If the claim was under your own motor policy, raise the issue with the insurer formally, keep its complaint reference and allow its normal response window. Most such complaints receive a final response within eight weeks; eligible customers can usually refer to the Ombudsman within six months of it.
The Ombudsman may require rectification, a new inspection or a fair financial remedy, but will assess the facts and policy rather than automatically accept the customer’s preferred garage quote.
Five steps to take
- 1
List each specific defect, date and
List each specific defect, date and suspected repair link, with photographs.
- 2
Tell the insurer and authorised repairer
Tell the insurer and authorised repairer in writing and request an inspection.
- 3
Ask for the technical explanation and
Ask for the technical explanation and proposed remedy, including safety checks.
- 4
Allow an appropriate remedy while preserving
Allow an appropriate remedy while preserving evidence and avoiding unauthorised extra charges.
- 5
If unresolved, make a formal insurer
If unresolved, make a formal insurer complaint and consider Ombudsman referral if eligible.
Keep your written record: note the claim reference, person contacted, decision and dates. Do not assume another party has accepted liability or costs until confirmed.
Poor Insurance Accident Repairs? How to Raise a Complaint: FAQs
Who is responsible for bad accident repairs?
If your own insurer arranged the workshop, it is generally responsible for the quality of that insured repair; separately contracted repairs may differ.
Can I ask for the work to be redone?
Yes, request an inspection and appropriate correction of evidenced defects under the policy and repair warranty.
What if paint colour does not match?
Document the difference in clear light and ask for the repairer or insurer to assess whether the result is acceptable.
Should I drive a car with post-repair warning lights?
Not if its safety is in doubt. Seek a qualified inspection before using a potentially unsafe vehicle.
Can I use another garage to fix it?
You may request this, but the insurer may have the right to inspect or remedy its appointed workshop’s work first.
What if the repairer denies causing the defect?
Ask for evidence and a technical assessment, then escalate the disagreement to the responsible insurer or contract party.
Will the Financial Ombudsman investigate?
It can review eligible complaints about an insurer’s repair handling and remedy, depending on the policy and evidence.
Do I have to pay for an independent report?
You might. Agree cost and whether it may be reimbursed before instructing an engineer.
Need help after an accident?
Sterling Accident can discuss qualifying vehicle recovery, damage assessment, authorised repairs and temporary mobility. It cannot guarantee liability decisions, insurer payments or contractual outcomes.